
Morris Schappes, Marxist and Jewish
Scholar, Dies at 97
By DOUGLAS MARTIN
Published: June 9, 2004
Correction Appended
Morris U. Schappes, who as a scholar, editor and activist strove to
combine his Marxist politics with a passion for Jewish history that was
kindled when he was in prison, died on Thursday at his home in Manhattan.
He was 97.
His death was announced
by Carol Jochnowitz, an editor of Jewish Currents, which Mr. Schappes
edited for four decades.
Mr. Schappes (pronounced SHAP-pess) was at the eye of a political storm in
1941 when he was fired by the City College of New York along with nearly
50 other Communist-leaning employees. He went to prison for perjury in
testifying to a state legislative committee on the case and used his time
behind bars to study Jewish history in preparation for writing
well-reviewed books on the subject.
He combined a passion for Jewish culture and history with a commitment to
atheistic Marxism. His magazine, originally a Soviet-backed Communist
organ, became something of an intellectual home for secular Jewish
leftists unwilling or unable to turn to religion or to more conservative
politics.
"There was an inherent tension between Marxism and Jewish identity," Ms.
Jochnowitz said of the readers of Jewish Currents. "Morris's career
straddled that divide."
His books included "A Documentary History of the Jews in the United
States: 1654-1875" (Citadel, 1950) and "The Jews in the United
States: A Pictorial History, 1654 to the Present" (Citadel, 1958). He
also edited a book on the poetry of Emma Lazarus, and another on her
letters.
Moise ben Haim Shapshilevich was born on May 3, 1907, in Kamenets-Podolsk,
Ukraine. His family returned to Brazil, where they had been living, and
bureaucrats there cut the family name to Schappes. On their way back to
Ukraine, his parents were marooned in New York by the start of World War
I.
His mother Americanized his name to Morris. He later added the initial "U"
to spruce up his byline as a sportswriter on the newspaper of City
College, where be began teaching after graduation in 1928. He earned a
master's degree from Columbia in 1930.
He wrote in Jewish Currents in 1982 that he became "the conspicuous 'red'
on campus," and joined the Communist Party in 1934. In 1936, the English
department decided to dismiss him for his political activities, but 500
students staged a sit-down strike and 2,000 participated in a funeral for
academic freedom. He was retained.
In 1940, the college offered a job to the philosopher Bertrand Russell,
but a groundswell of opposition to his political and other viewpoints
doomed the appointment. A result of the case was the formation of the
Rapp-Coudert Committee to investigate City College.
Under oath, Mr. Schappes told the panel that he could name only three
Communists at the college, two of them dead and one of them known to be a
party organizer. After William Martin Canning, a history instructor, named
about 50 employees as Communists, Mr. Schappes was convicted of perjury.
He served 13 1/2 months in state prisons. He learned Hebrew from another
inmate and began to attend Sabbath services after the Jewish chaplain
agreed that he would not have to pray. He also studied Jewish history, an
interest he said stemmed from his studies of black history.
After his release he worked in a war production factory in Long Island
City, Queens. In November 1946, he became a member of the editorial board
of Jewish Life.
It is not clear when Mr. Schappes broke with the Communist Party, but at
least one account, J. Edgar Hoover's book "Masters of Deceit,"
suggests that Mr. Schappes was still active as late as 1957. By 1958, Ms.
Jochnowitz said, the Jewish Life staff had become "anguished" by the
Soviet Union's abrupt discarding of Stalin and the only sort of Communism
they had known. They started Jewish Currents that year as a voice
independent of Moscow, both in content and financing.
The Communist Party U.S.A. was not pleased, warning in 1969 that Jewish
Currents was slipping into "a blind alley of Jewish nationalism." In 1977
Mr. Schappes expressed the fear that there might be an "eventual and
inevitable total disappearance and obliteration of Jewish life in the
Soviet Union."
He became a prominent commentator on Jewish affairs, and pressed his case
that Shakespeare was anti-Semitic. His wife, Sonya Laffer, died in 1992,
and he leaves no immediate survivors.
In 1981, the faculty senate of City College apologized for firing him and
his colleagues.
Correction: June 13, 2004, Sunday
An obituary on Wednesday about Morris U. Schappes, a magazine editor with
interests in Marxist politics and Jewish culture, misstated remarks about
his work and his views by Carol Jochnowitz, an editor of Jewish Currents,
the magazine he edited for four decades. In citing "an inherent tension
between Marxism and Jewish identity," Ms. Jochnowitz said, she was
speaking in general terms, not necessarily describing readers of the
magazine. She said Mr. Schappes was stunned in the 1950's by Soviet
revelations of Stalin's brutality, not about the Soviet Union's decision
to discredit his rule.
copyright 2004 © New York Times |